With A Little Help From Your Friends

Ever since hearing about the blogs of Al Upton’s 3rd graders being at least temporarily shut down because of fears that too much student information was being disclosed, I’ve wondered how I could help the situation. After much thought I decided to approach the situation with my 5th graders through what we have been learning about the Revolutionary War, and how the United States formed a new government. We focused on freedom of speech and why the founding fathers designed our government with a separation of powers … all the issues associated with “kings” and their abuse of power over the centuries and how that effected how our government was designed.

We talked about how on the one hand we have the freedom of speech and can say what we want, but that we can’t yell “Fire” in a crowded building because people would be put in danger. We also talked about swaying public opinion with a well thought out argument versus  complaining and ranting and coming across negatively. Next we talked about the situation with Al’s students and our 1 day experience with having our blogs blocked. That really hit home with them which I was glad to see. They tend to take life on the chin and not get riled about the important things. They wanted to express themselves about blogging and why Al’s students should blog from an academic standpoint and how they could be safe blogging and their parents should allow it based on following some of the guidelines we follow.

So after a group brainstorm students made their points about the value of blogging and why the Minilegends’ parents and school should support it. They left the comments on Al’s post (now well over 100 comments total) and felt like maybe they had learned something and done some good. I felt it was time well spent and helped them make some connections with history.

Learning is messy!

Blogged with the Flock Browser

Tags: ,

Nevada Ranks 50th In High School Graduation Rate – And There Is A Co$t

a new report by the Alliance for Excellent Education again finds my state wanting when it comes to education. One thing that I note with interest is that our governor recently cut about the same amount from K-12 education as would be saved EACH YEAR if just 5% more males graduated from high school. Since Nevada funds schools at close to 50th in the country it seems it might be a good investment for the future to fund schools at a higher rate and offer more high school programs that are not college prep … like most are now … even though most students don’t go on to college. Maybe providing engaging curriculum that leads to a high school diploma without having to take all the math and higher level science we demand now would actually lead to students getting a better education. I’m not saying do away with the college prep track, but it’s not for everybody. Would some students that graduate with the non-college prep degree still go to college via community college? And some take that degree and go on to a 4 year degree? Probably not a huge number, but I believe so, especially once they been in the real world for awhile and see how that could benefit them. They’ll be older and more mature and perhaps better understand the value of further education. Here are some of the gory details from the report:

Nevada would save more than $230.1 million in health care costs during the lifetimes of each class of dropouts if they had graduated from high school, and if the male graduation rate increased by just 5 percent the state would see an additional $78.4 million a year in crime-related savings and additional revenue.

The 16,000 students who didn’t graduate in 2007 will cost themselves $4.2 billion in a loss of lifetime earnings by dropping out of high school.

Learning is messy!

Blogged with Flock

Are We “Bridging Differences” Finally?

Based on a comment I left on a post over at Weblogg-ed.

I’ve been following “Bridging Differences” for quite awhile and so have seen how these two women who at first seemed far apart in their theories and experiences in education have been coming more and more to common ground – kind of shows the value of talking … hashing things out, diplomacy … um but I digress. We’ve heard/seen the same when the Stagers’ and the Richardsons’ (and others) who at times seem to be at odds over things get together to “have at it” in person seem to come away realizing they are not so far apart really.

My other take away here is that however we define or identify the members of those pushing for change in education that are not “techies” – those of us that are believers in educational technology should go out of our way to embrace and converse with them as allies in this whole change process. We will not agree on everything, but much more than not, and we will have magnified and enriched our voices.

Also note that Ms. Meier and Ms. Ravitch are blogging … and I note more and more they are linking to other sources and resources … unless they have someone else doing that for them they are making steps, perhaps unknowingly, towards embracing technology as a communicative and educational lever.

Those in power have been casting aspersions on blogging and bloggers as not having value, of being pawns in a conspiracy to undermine democracy, and all that is good. We all know that TV news, newspapers, magazines … the lot … have never been accused of that … they are sacrosanct … umm yeah.

One of the strongest lessons, in my opinion, from the whole Watergate mess was how the Nixon administration and their surrogates attacked Woodward and Bernstein and the Washington Post as being slanted and biased and off the mark wrong … and we know how that turned out. Both Meiers and Ravitch have faced similar attacks.

This country in-particular has been engaged in a raucous debate over education for a long time and that has been enhanced since the “deployment” of NCLB. Perhaps like Meirs and Ravitch we will begin to come to some common ground and bridge some … or a lot of our differences.

Learning is messy!

Blogged with Flock

Tags:

Write It!

Years ago at a language arts in-service training, one of the presenters showed us a game called “Write It!”. I used it a few times, tweaked it a bit, and now its one of my favorite writing activities, and my students’ too.

Because note writing in class between students is usually about spreading rumors or setting up a fight or other negative issue, and makes paying attention or staying on task problematic, I have a strict rule against note writing unless we’re playing “Write It!”

The rules while playing Write It! Are straight forward:

Absolutely No Talking Or Making Noises. ( Duh! – you WRITE IT! – get it?)
No Airmail (no tossing a note to someone – you must place it on the table in front of them).
No Put Downs
No Foul Language
You Must Write Notes To Many Different Students, Not Just Your Friends.

The steps to playing the game are also simple:

1) Put your name on your note. (so the recipient knows who it is from)
2) Make a nice comment. (“I like your shirt” or “You played well during our soccer game at recess.” NOT – “Well you’re not as ugly today as you were yesterday! – An actual positive comment.
3) Ask a question. (“Which Sponge Bob is your favorite?” or “Have you seen Such and Such movie?”)
4) Deliver It! (Walk the note to the person and set it on their desk in front of them).
5) Answer It. (Answer the question you were asked and deliver it back to them.) Now that note is dead. If you have another question for the same student you must send a new note, with a NEW nice comment and a new question.

I have students tear one sheet of paper into eight note-sized pieces to start, they can get more paper as needed. I strictly enforce the no talking rule, which includes laughing while delivering a note. The first time a student is talking they are out of the game – they may not write notes, get notes or read notes they already received. After 3 to 5 minutes I let them back in with the proviso that the next time they are talking they are done for the game. I almost NEVER kick someone out twice.

So what happens? Kids communicate like crazy. I tell students if they can’t decipher handwriting or meaning – don’t answer the note. If you delivered a note and it never gets answered you might need to resend it and be more careful. This forces students to really think hard about spelling and meaning. They write and write and write. I’ve had games go for 45 minutes, but that is rare. I usually stop after 15 to 20 minutes and even 8 to 10 minutes is fun and leads to plenty of writing. AND kids get lots of “nice comments” from other students and questions about what they are doing and what they like, and more – and they learn more about each other.

We talk about the ethics of comments and questions and including students that you know often aren’t – and it almost always goes well. I have had students bring me notes with inappropriate “nice comments” a few times in all the years I have played this, but we have a discussion with the parties involved and work it out. BTW – does this have a ring to it? Does this sound like similar ethics to those we espouse students to have while online? Yes – which is what lead to me blogging about this. We played this game on Friday and afterwards several students mentioned how this was just like what we have talked about when making comments on blogs or even writing posts and not rumor mongering about someone.

After our game Friday I asked my students what they like about Write It! Students agreed that they send notes and get notes from students they don’t usually talk to. Someone said it was like texting. I asked how many had cell phones (I already knew the answer … almost all of them) and how many texted. Almost all hands went up. How many enjoy texting and text a lot? – about a third (9) raised their hands. How many really don’t text much and don’t really enjoy it? – Also about a third. How many like playing Write It!? – Enthusiastically all hands went up.
Give Write It! A try!

Learning is messy!

Blogged with Flock

Tags: , ,

PSSSST …. Lunar Eclipse Wednesday Night (North America) … Pass It On!!!

Wednesday night in North America there will be a lunar eclipse. Here is a link to The NASA Eclipse Home Page. I’m hoping to get my 5th graders to observe and blog about it. Keep it safe … it will be after dark so talk to students about not going out without supervision (depending on circumstances of course).

Should be a good “messy” learning experience.

Blogged with Flock

As Time Goes By NCLB Just Looks Better and Better … NOT!

An article about a new study shows AGAIN much of the hoopla about Texas schools being the shining example that prove the wisdom of NCLB is … um … wrong!

“The study shows that Texas’ public school accountability system, the model for the national No Child Left Behind Act, directly contributes to lower graduation rates.”

Among other troubling findings is this one:

“What’s more, the study indicated that the higher the stakes and the longer such an accountability system governs schools, the more school personnel view students not as children to educate but as potential liabilities or assets for their school’s performance indicators, their own careers or their school’s funding.”
From an article in The Austin Business Journal

I would provide other quotes, but the article is very short. The study was done by Rice University and the University of Texas at Austin.

Learning is messy!

Blogged with Flock

New Skype Movie

Skype sent a camera crew to our classroom back in October to make a movie about how we used Skype to include a classmate with leukemia using video-conferencing. Even though Celest attends school regularly now, that day they had her stay home and attend school via Skype. The crew spent the morning in our classroom and the afternoon at Celest’s.

What is nice about this movie is that it gives you the real sense of how well we were able to interact using video-conferencing. If you know the story you’ll hear it again. Click here or the photo to see the video.

Learning is messy.

Blogged with Flock

Tags: ,

Is This An Example Of 21st Century Skills???

My wife was correcting a math page done by her 4th graders. She finds one where the print is “grainy” … not like the rest. Why? Turns out one student lost their page … calls friend who has already completed problems … so the friend makes a copy and “whites out” the answers and the work they did, then faxes new “blank” page to classmate.

Is this what we mean by 21st century skills??? Part of me says yes,
and part ….

Learning is messy.

Blogged with Flock

Tags: